Sort by: title|author|date (Currently sorted by date)

Live Blogging PatCon 2 at BCLS

Posted in Blog, Featured, Patent | Posted by John Malato

The first round of talks gave 15 minutes for presentation and 15 for Q&A. The first presenters were Gaia Bernstein, Tun-Jen Chiang and Carliss Balwin. 1. For Bernstein, user adoption problems are proportional to the novelty and complexity of the hardware in question, and referencing Benjamin, should be resolved with the formation of an office [...]

Read More

Modeling the University Technology Licensee

Posted in Blog, Featured, Other Intellectual Property, Patent | Posted by John Malato

The Technology Adoption Problem Established corporations (hereafter firms) make decisions about when and which technologies to adopt to increase revenues and stay competitive. The types of technologies they adopt are diverse, from information technology infrastructures that facilitate communication and customer service to manufacturing equipment that increase output and precision. The process a firm undergoes in [...]

Read More

University Spin Outs: An Annotated Lifecycle

Posted in Blog, Featured, Other Intellectual Property | Posted by John Malato

Josef Solterer, writing in 1950, quipped that “If there were no entrepreneurs at all, i.e. all acts are merely repetitive, then all durable goods could be replaced only” (Solterer, 1950).[i] His statement cuts at the heart of the purpose and value of the entrepreneur: to propel an otherwise stagnant society towards progress, improvement, and, generally, [...]

Read More

Process Patents: You Can’t Monopolize Hedging

Posted in Blog, Patent | Posted by John Malato

Bilski v. Kappos is a 2010 Supreme Court case concerning process patents, as allowed under section 101 and defined under section 100 as a “process, art or method, include[ing] a new use of a known process, machine, manufacture, composition of matter, or material.” At issue in Bilski is whether patent protection should be granted over [...]

Read More

Contemporary University Technology Transfer

Posted in Blog, Other Intellectual Property, Patent | Posted by John Malato

          This article attempts to describe the contemporary landscape of University Technology Transfer. Part 1 presents a brief history of the field. Part 2 summarizes the Litan-Mitchell model of university tech transfer and licensing optimization. Part 3 augments this optimization model. Part 4 supplements the licensing gap with entrepreneurial considerations. I.                    University Technology Transfer: An [...]

Read More

Determining Efficient Patent Durations by Subject Matter

Posted in Blog, Patent | Posted by John Malato

Introduction In his “Taking the Utilitarian Basis for Patent Law Seriously” Professor Olson suggests we reevaluate the current US patent regime with an eye for economic efficiency.[1] Olson points out that granting a patent is only efficient when the social benefits flowing not from the invention, but the patent itself, outweigh the deadweight loss to [...]

Read More

DIGITAL SAMPLING OF MUSIC AND COPYRIGHTS: IS IT INFRINGEMENT, FAIR USE, OR SHOULD WE JUST FLIP A COIN?

Posted in All Articles, Copyright, Featured | Posted by admin

D.J. Girl Talk is one of the budding artists in the music industry today, and his instrument is a laptop. D.J. Girl Talk (hereinafter also referred to as “Girl Talk”), whose real name is Gregg Gillis, “samples,” or uses short clips, from other artists’ songs to create popular dance music. Girl Talk’s songs combine old, [...]

Read More

File Sharing: A Tool for Innovation, or a Criminal Instrument?

Posted in Computing, Copyright, Featured, Uncategorized | Posted by admin

The dawn of peer-to-peer networks and the subsequent rise of file sharing over the Internet have proved to be a considerable threat to the revenues of the Recording Industry Association of America (“RIAA”) and the international music community.  While early music downloading across peer-to-peer networks on the Internet was largely limited “to college students with [...]

Read More

AVOID THE RAINY DAY: SURVEY OF U.S. CLOUD COMPUTING CASELAW

AVOID THE RAINY DAY: SURVEY OF U.S. CLOUD COMPUTING CASELAW

Cloud computing, a computer networking model that gives users on-demand access to shared software applications and data storage, [1] is becoming increasingly popular among businesses and individuals. For example, if you use Google’s Gmail [2] for your email and calendaring, or Snapfish [3] for your online photo sharing and storage; or if your business remotely [...]

Read More

ON FEDERAL PREEMPTION OF CONTRACTUAL FIRST SALE WAIVERS

Posted in All Articles, Copyright, Featured | Posted by admin
ON FEDERAL PREEMPTION OF CONTRACTUAL FIRST SALE WAIVERS

History has venerated the free transfer of tangible property, and this is partly why students of copyright law can purchase their textbooks “used” at discount prices. [1] If 2L Dave buys Professor William Patry’s copyright treatise at the bookstore, Dave acquires title to the book and can freely transfer it to thrifty 1L Sara the [...]

Read More

A CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT TO DECEIVE?: THE FIRST AMENDMENT IMPLICATIONS OF REGULATING PAY PER CLICK

Posted in All Articles, Copyright, Featured, Trademark | Posted by admin
A CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT TO DECEIVE?: THE FIRST AMENDMENT IMPLICATIONS OF REGULATING PAY PER CLICK

Mainstream search engines derive their principal source of revenue from advertising. [1] Pay Per Click Advertising (hereinafter “Paid Placement”) is one of the most widely utilized advertising practices, offering content providers the opportunity to create short textual advertisements hyperlinked to their website. [2] Providers bid on keywords associated with their advertisement, [3] and when a [...]

Read More

PATENT LITIGATION: WHAT ABOUT QUALIFICATION STANDARDS FOR COURT APPOINTED EXPERTS?

Posted in All Articles, Featured, Patent | Posted by admin
PATENT LITIGATION: WHAT ABOUT QUALIFICATION STANDARDS FOR COURT APPOINTED EXPERTS?

Abstract–“The descriptions in patents are not addressed to the public generally, to lawyers or to judges, but, as [35 U.S.C.] section 112 states, to those skilled in the art to which the invention pertains ***.” [1] This leads to a tenet of patent law, that the meaning of patents and claim terms must be construed [...]

Read More

PROVERIS v. INNOVASYSTEMS: REDEFINING A PATENTED INVENTION UNDER § 271(E)(1): An Examination of the Federal Circuit’s Narrowing of the § 271(e)(1) “Safe Harbor” Exemption

Posted in All Articles, Featured, Patent | Posted by admin
PROVERIS v. INNOVASYSTEMS: REDEFINING A PATENTED INVENTION UNDER § 271(E)(1): An Examination of the Federal Circuit's Narrowing of the § 271(e)(1) “Safe Harbor” Exemption

The Food and Drug Administration’s (“FDA”) regulation of drugs and medical devices impacts the everyday lives of Americans in both noticeable and inconspicuous ways. [1] For example, a recall of contaminated food or adulterated pharmaceuticals illustrates how the FDA noticeably affects impacts our everyday lives. [2] Additionally, unobservable consequences springing from the overlap between FDA [...]

Read More

THE PRESIDENTIAL RIGHT OF PUBLICITY

THE PRESIDENTIAL RIGHT OF PUBLICITY

Although the right of publicity has historically been a cause of action invoked by celebrities to protect themselves from an extensive range of conduct, the question remains whether non-traditional celebrities deserve the same rights. [2] Can President Obama protect against the unauthorized use of his image since he has arguably attained celebrity-like status? I believe [...]

Read More

THE BIOLOGICS PRICE COMPETITION AND INNOVATION ACT: INNOVATION MUST COME BEFORE PRICE COMPETITION

Posted in All Articles, Patent | Posted by admin
THE BIOLOGICS PRICE COMPETITION AND INNOVATION ACT: INNOVATION MUST COME BEFORE PRICE COMPETITION

Unlike traditional pharmaceutical drugs, which are small molecule compounds synthesized by chemists, biologics are typically large molecules that are produced in living things. [1] [2] Breakthroughs in the life sciences over the last two decades have led to new biologically derived treatments for debilitating diseases including autoimmune diseases, metabolic disorders, degenerative diseases, blood disorders, and [...]

Read More

“INDECENT” DECEPTION: THE ROLE OF COMMUNICATIONS DECENCY ACT § 230 IN BALANCING CONSUMER AND MARKETER INTERESTS ONLINE

Posted in All Articles, Computing | Posted by admin
“INDECENT” DECEPTION: THE ROLE OF COMMUNICATIONS DECENCY ACT § 230 IN BALANCING CONSUMER AND MARKETER INTERESTS ONLINE

“[T]he Internet represents a brave new world of free speech … [it] is fundamentally different from traditional forms of mass communication in at least three important respects. First, the Internet is capable of maintaining an unlimited number of information sources …, Second, the Internet has no “gatekeepers”–no publishers or editors controlling the distribution of information [...]

Read More

THE UNLITIGATED CASE: A STUDY OF THE LEGALITY OF GUITAR TABLATURES

Posted in All Articles, Computing, Copyright | Posted by admin
THE UNLITIGATED CASE: A STUDY OF THE LEGALITY OF GUITAR TABLATURES

Abstract–Guitar tablature Web sites have been the subject of recent cease-and-desist letters, forcing most to shut down. Litigation has been side-stepped with the arrival of new creative means to continue operation. The case that may have gone to court is discussed here, ranging from the appropriate legal claims of copyright infringement to the fair-use-defense arguments [...]

Read More

ROUNDING UP PLANT PATENTS & OTHER GROWING PATENT CONCERNS A COMMENT ON MONSANTO v. SCHMEISER

Posted in All Articles, Patent | Posted by admin
ROUNDING UP PLANT PATENTS & OTHER GROWING PATENT CONCERNS A COMMENT ON MONSANTO v. SCHMEISER

On the heels of their ubiquitous and controversial decision in Harvard College v. Canada (Commissioner of Patents) (the so-called ‘Harvard Mouse’ case), [1] the Canadian Courts were soon asked to re-consider the issues surrounding the patentability of biotechnological inventions in Monsanto v. Schmeiser. [2] Unlike Harvard Mouse, this matter was an infringement action. At the [...]

Read More

CAN AN INTERNET REFERENCE BE A “PRINTED PUBLICATION”?

Posted in All Articles, Computing, Patent | Posted by admin
CAN AN INTERNET REFERENCE BE A “PRINTED PUBLICATION”?

Much of the information to the public is provided by the Internet today. The Internet has also become increasingly popular among researchers who now turn to it for articles, journals, and online databases. [2] Therefore, the question of whether an Internet reference is a “printed publication” is critical for today’s inventors, patent attorneys, and judges. [...]

Read More

UTILITY MODELS AND THEIR COMPARISON WITH PATENTS AND IMPLICATIONS FOR THE US INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY LAW SYSTEM

Posted in All Articles, Patent | Posted by admin
UTILITY MODELS AND THEIR COMPARISON WITH PATENTS AND IMPLICATIONS FOR THE US INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY LAW SYSTEM

Abstract–European Patent Office (EPO) practice, guided by the European Patent Convention (EPC) is in many aspects very similar to Europe’s national patent practice, such as the German patent law. In this article, the US practitioner is briefly reminded of some of the considerable differences between US Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) patent prosecution practice and [...]

Read More