A Shoveler’s Manifesto: Can I Lay Claim To That Parking Space?

Should I have a property right in the parking space I laboriously shoveled out after yet another New England winter storm?  Can I lay any legal claim to that space when I leave it, such as by placing a marker of some kind in it?  Should I be entitled to slash the tires or break the windows of a car that takes the space I shoveled out?

I’m sure these thoughts seem absurd (especially to those outside of urban areas in New England), but I can’t help but ponder them when I spend hours trying to find, clear out and keep a parking spot on my street in Somerville, MA (New England’s most densely populated city).  It doesn’t help matters when the city declares a snow emergency, towing cars parked on the even side of the street and cutting the number of available parking spaces in half.

The visceral notion that “I shoveled it, I should get to keep it,” rings true in a classic Lockean way: the labor of your body and the work of your hands is properly yours.  See John Locke, Second Treatise of Civil Government, Chapter 5, §27.  But from a modern legal standpoint, it would seem impossible for a private citizen to obtain any kind of property right in what is certainly government property.  It’s not the wild west, you can’t stake a claim to a piece of pavement simply because you surveyed it, dusted it off and tied your horse up there.  Methods other than simply staking your claim don’t look promising.  Generally, adverse possession is not an option, as most States explicitly exempt public roadways from adverse possession by statute.  See, e.g., Colo. Rev. Stat. § 38-41-101(2) (2008).  Notably, Massachusetts is an exception to this rule, only disallowing adverse possession against the commonwealth and its political subdivisions except in connection with land used for certain environmental purposes.  See Mass. Gen. L. Ch. 260, §31; Lawrence v. Concord, 439 Mass. 416 (2003).  Still, because of the unlikelihood of occupying a city parking space for 20 years in any urban area of the Commonwealth without someone breaking the continuity, adverse possession isn’t a realistic option, even in Massachusetts.

Nonetheless, a longstanding snowstorm practice, especially in South Boston, is to put lawn furniture, traffic cones, trash cans, cinderblocks and any other large object in resident-cleared parking spaces in order to reserve them.  These rights are vigorously defended in that neighborhood, resulting in the aforementioned slashed tires, broken windows, and even the occasional assault.  This is a place where you simply do NOT want to take someone’s clearly marked space.

Despite the questionable legality of this process, it has been sanctioned by Boston mayor Thomas M. Menino, to a limited extent.  In 2003, in response to some South Boston residents reserving spaces for three weeks after a two-inch snowfall, Menino put in place a 48-hour cap on the reservation of shoveled out spaces, implicitly endorsing the practice.  A long battle between Menino’s garbage crews (who pick up the milk crates, barrels and shopping carts used to save spaces) and South Boston residents have ensued, epitomized by South Boston city councilor James M. Kelly’s declaration to Menino that “I’ve got more barrels than he’s got trucks.”

It’s questionable whether Menino even has the authority to allow the private reservation of public property, even for a limited time, but only in the most academic sense.  The fact is that parking spaces will continue to be reserved in South Boston and other urban areas of Massachusetts, whether legally or not, and municipalities will implement their own policies to prevent, curtail or begrudgingly accept the practice for practicality’s sake.  So as I continue to battle the relentlessly falling snow, increasingly discolored by salt, sand and cat litter, I will consider the prospect of defending the product of my labor as John Locke would say I should… and probably just look for another parking space.

3 Comments

• 

  By scene hairstyles, December 31, 2009 @ 1:22 am

  thank you for this post..!

• 

  By Swankydave, February 27, 2010 @ 12:08 am

  On a not-so serious not, you have to admit, some of the stuff you see out there is pretty funny. I found this blog: http://www.snowparking.com.

• 

  By jbroses, February 27, 2010 @ 3:21 pm

  That’s one of the best websites I’ve ever seen. I’m definitely going to look for good spot-savers and submit them. Great find!

Other Links to this Post

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment